Direct Producers' Liability for Non-conformity and the Sellers' Right of Redress
E-Book, Englisch, 614 Seiten, Format (B × H): 160 mm x 240 mm
ISBN: 978-3-86653-862-7
Verlag: Otto Schmidt
Format: PDF
Kopierschutz: Adobe DRM (»Systemvoraussetzungen)
Autoren/Hrsg.
Fachgebiete
Weitere Infos & Material
1;Acknowledgements;6
2;List of Contributors;8
3;Table of Contents;12
4;Part 1 European Perspectives on Producers’ Liability;16
4.1;Comparative Report;18
4.1.1;A. Introduction;18
4.1.2;B. Direct Producers’ Liability for Non-conformity in Europe;22
4.1.3;C. The Right of Redress in Europe;51
4.1.4;D. Towards a European Direct Producers’ Liability?;73
5;Part 2 Horizontal Perspectives;90
5.1;New Law Based on Old Rules: Antecedents and Paragons of the Modern Law on Producers’ Liability;92
5.1.1;A. Introduction;92
5.1.2;B. Old Legal Devices …;93
5.1.3;C. … and New Conflicts;100
5.1.4;D. The Action Directe: A Model for Europe?;112
5.1.5;E. Epilogue;119
5.2;Impacts of Warranty Claims on Consumers’ Complaint Behaviour and Producer’s Reputation: A Behavioural Psychology Analysis and Empirical Findings;120
5.2.1;A. Introduction;120
5.2.2;B. Perception and Evaluation of Warranties;122
5.2.3;C. Exercising Warranty Rights: Consumers’ Complaint Behaviour;130
5.2.4;D. Impacts of a Direct Claim on Producer’s Reputation;134
5.2.5;E. Conclusion;138
5.3;Consumer Sales Law from an Economic Perspective;140
5.3.1;A. Introduction;140
5.3.2;B. Quality Deterioration and the Market Mechanism;141
5.3.3;C. Economic Analysis of Directive 99/44 and Its Implementation in Some Member States;147
5.3.4;D. Must Consumer Sales Law Be Harmonised?;159
5.3.5;E. Conclusions;163
5.4;Direct Producers’ Liability and Sellers’ Right of Redress in Private International Law;166
5.4.1;A. Introduction;166
5.4.2;B. The Sellers’ Right of Redress along the Chain of Contracts;167
5.4.3;C. Sellers’ Right of Redress in Form of an Action Directe;176
5.4.4;D. (Planned) Direct Producers’ Liability;180
5.4.5;E. Summary and Outlook;181
6;Part 3 Producers’ Liability and the Sellers’ Right of Redress in European Legal Orders;184
6.1;Public Statements by Producers, Commercial Guarantees and the Right of Redress in Austrian Law after the Transposition of Directive 99/ 44;186
6.1.1;A. The Legal Situation before the Transposition of Directive 99/444;186
6.1.2;B. The Legal Situation after the Transposition of Directive 99/44;189
6.1.3;C. Direct Producer’s Liability?;197
6.1.4;D. Rights of Redress (Art. 4 Directive 99/44);200
6.1.5;E. Outlook;207
6.2;Rights of Redress and Direct Producer’s Liability in Consumer Sales in Belgium: a Critical Appraisal;210
6.2.1;A. Introduction;210
6.2.2;B. Final Seller’s Liability to the Buyer;210
6.2.3;C. Producer’s Liability towards the Buyer and the Final Seller;215
6.2.4;D. Commercial Guarantees from the Producer;218
6.2.5;E. Conclusion;221
6.2.6;F. Outlook;222
6.3;The Producer’s and Seller’s Liability under Bulgarian Law;226
6.3.1;A. Introduction;226
6.3.2;B. Various Regimes for Sale Contracts;226
6.3.3;C. Rights of the Buyer under the CPA and OCA;226
6.3.4;D. Raising a Claim;231
6.3.5;E. Respondent;232
6.3.6;F. Right of Redress;233
6.3.7;G. Assessment;236
6.3.8;H. Conclusion;237
6.4;Direct Liability of Previous Seller, Supplier and Producer in Danish Law;238
6.4.1;A. Introduction;238
6.4.2;B. Traditional Rights and Remedies of a Buyer Inter Partes;240
6.4.3;C. Contractual Guarantees to the Benefit of a Buyer;251
6.4.4;D. Direct Claim against Previous Seller, Supplier and Producer;260
6.4.5;E. Final Seller’s Right to Redress;268
6.4.6;F. Conclusion and Outlook;269
6.5;An English Perspective on Producers’ Liability;270
6.5.1;A. Introduction;270
6.5.2;B. The Rights of the Consumer against the Seller;270
6.5.3;C. Consumer Guarantees;277
6.5.4;D. The Seller’s Right of Redress;279
6.5.5;E. Towards Producer Liability?;286
6.5.6;F. Conclusions;288
6.6;Direct Producers’ Liability and the Sellers’ Right of Redress in Estonia;290
6.6.1;A. Introduction;290
6.6.2;B. Legal Situation before the Transposition of the Directive 99/44;291
6.6.3;C. Transposition of the Directive 99/44 into the Estonian Legal System;292
6.6.4;D. Claims under the Sales Contract;294
6.6.5;E. Producers’ Direct Liability;298
6.6.6;F. Right of Redress;302
6.6.7;G. Conclusion;307
6.7;A Finnish Perspective on Producers’ Liability;310
6.7.1;A. Introduction;310
6.7.2;B. Commercial Guarantees;311
6.7.3;C. Direct Producer’s Liability;315
6.7.4;D. Rights of Redress;322
6.7.5;E. Outlook;324
6.8;The French “ Action Directe”: The Justification for Going beyond Privity;326
6.8.1;A. Introduction;326
6.8.2;B. The Theoretical Foundations of the Direct Action;327
6.8.3;C. The Sources of the Sellers’ and Producers’ Liability;329
6.8.4;D. The Scope of the Direct Action;333
6.8.5;E. Climbing up the Chain of Contract: The Sellers’ Remedies;335
6.8.6;F. Conclusions;336
6.9;Direct Producer’s Liability and the Final Seller’s Right of Redress in Germany;338
6.9.1;A. Introduction;338
6.9.2;B. The Seller’s Liability for the Producer’s Statements;338
6.9.3;C. Commercial Guarantees;345
6.9.4;D. Direct Producers’ Liability;348
6.9.5;E. Right of Redress;348
6.9.6;F. Conclusion and Outlook;355
6.10;Direct Producers’ Liability, Commercial Guarantees and the Seller’s Right of Redress in Greek Civil Law;356
6.10.1;A. Introduction Greek Civil Law;356
6.10.2;B. The Implementation of the Directive 99/44;356
6.10.3;C. Direct Producers’ Liability?;359
6.10.4;D. Commercial Guarantees in Greek Law;360
6.10.5;E. The Seller’s Right of Redress;364
6.10.6;F. Outlook;367
6.11;The Implementation of the Directive 99/44 into Hungarian Law and the Legal Institution of the Direct Producers’ Liability;368
6.11.1;A. Introduction;368
6.11.2;B. The Legal Situation prior to Implementation;370
6.11.3;C. Right of Redress;379
6.11.4;D. Direct Producers’ Liability and the Draft of the New Hungarian Civil Code;381
6.11.5;E. Outlook;385
6.12;The Buyer, the Seller, the Producer and the Law in Ireland;386
6.12.1;A. Introduction;386
6.12.2;B. Legal Guarantees – Consumer Claims against the Seller;388
6.12.3;C. Commercial Guarantees;398
6.12.4;D. Direct Producer Liability;401
6.12.5;E. Right of Redress;403
6.12.6;F. Concluding Remarks;404
6.13;Direct Producers’ Liability and the Final Seller’s Right of Redress in Italy;406
6.13.1;A. Introduction;406
6.13.2;B. Legal Situation before and after the Transposition of Directive 99/ 44;406
6.13.3;C. Commercial Guarantees;414
6.13.4;D. Direct Producers’ Liability?;422
6.13.5;E. Rights of Redress under Art. 4 Directive 99/44;427
6.13.6;F. Conclusions;431
6.14;Direct Producers’ Liability and the Sellers’ Right of Redress – Lithuanian Perspective;432
6.14.1;A. Introduction;432
6.14.2;B. Legal Situation before the Transposition of the Directive 99/44;432
6.14.3;C. Legal Situation after the Transposition of the Directive 99/44;433
6.14.4;D. Outlook on Direct Producers’ Liability;440
6.15;Direct Producers’ Liability and Sellers’ Rights of Redress under Maltese Law;442
6.15.1;A. Introduction;442
6.15.2;B. The Seller’s Liability for the Producer’s Statements;444
6.15.3;C. Commercial Guarantees;452
6.15.4;D. The Direct Liability of Producers;455
6.15.5;E. Right of Redress of the Final Seller against the Previous Suppliers in the Chain and the Producer;457
6.15.6;F. Conclusion;458
6.16;Recourse and Direct Action in the Netherlands: a Dutch Treat?;460
6.16.1;A. Introduction;460
6.16.2;B. General Remarks;460
6.16.3;C. Claims against the Final Seller;462
6.16.4;D. Commercial Guarantees;464
6.16.5;E. Rights of Redress;466
6.16.6;F. Direct Claim against the Producer;470
6.16.7;G. Conclusions;474
6.17;The Consumer’s Direct Claims against Parties to Previous Contracts and the Seller’s Right of Redress in Norway;476
6.17.1;A. Introduction;476
6.17.2;B. Direct Claims against Parties to Previous Contracts;478
6.17.3;C. Information Liability;485
6.17.4;D. Rights of Redress;485
6.17.5;E. Commercial Guarantees;487
6.17.6;F. Outlook;489
6.18;Direct Producer’s Liability and the Seller’s Right of Redress in Poland;490
6.18.1;A. Introduction;490
6.18.2;B. Liability of the Seller for Defects under the Civil Code. Implementation of the Directive and Liability for Non- conformity of Consumer Goods;491
6.18.3;C. Product Claims: How Do they Shape Expectations about Products and the Liability for Defects and Non- conformity?;496
6.18.4;D. The Seller’s Right of Recourse;500
6.18.5;E. Direct Liability of the Producer in the Future?;503
6.19;Direct Producers’ Liability and the Sellers’ Right of Redress in Portugal;506
6.19.1;A. Introduction;506
6.19.2;B. Legal Situation in Portuguese Law before and after the Transposition of Directive 99/ 44;506
6.19.3;C. Rights of Redress;512
6.19.4;D. Direct Producers’ Liability;514
6.19.5;E. Commercial Guarantees;517
6.19.6;F. Outlook;518
6.20;Producers’ Liability for Non-conformity in Scots Law;520
6.20.1;A. Introduction;520
6.20.2;B. Consumer Actions against the Seller;520
6.20.3;C. Consumer Actions against the Producer Based on Implied Terms;520
6.20.4;D. Actions Based on Guarantees;521
6.20.5;E. Actions by the Seller against his Supplier;525
6.20.6;F. Consumer Actions against the Producer Based in Delict;525
6.20.7;G. Conclusion;528
6.21;Direct Liability of the Producer and the Seller’s Right of Redress in Spain;530
6.21.1;A. Legal Protection of the Buyer;530
6.21.2;B. Additional Commercial Guarantee;546
6.21.3;C. The Liability of the Producer in the Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007;551
6.21.4;D. The Action for an Indemnity from the Party who Was Liable to the Consumer. The Right of Redress;557
6.21.5;E. Conclusion;559
6.22;Direct Producers’ Liability and the Seller’s Right of Redress According to Swedish Law;562
6.22.1;A. Introduction;562
6.22.2;B. Legal Situation before and after the Transposition of the Directive 99/ 44;562
6.22.3;C. The Consumers Claim against the Seller;564
6.22.4;D. Commercial Guarantees: Guarantee Claims against the Producer ( Art. 6 Directive 99/ 44);566
6.22.5;E. Direct Producers’ Liability;567
6.22.6;F. Rights of Redress;576
6.22.7;G. Outlook;576
6.23;Producer’s and Seller’s Liability under Swiss Law Law A Comparative Analysis under European Perspectives;578
6.23.1;A. Introduction;578
6.23.2;B. Legal Situation Regarding Claims by the Buyer in Switzerland;580
6.23.3;C. Commercial Guarantees;589
6.23.4;D. Rights of Redress;590
6.23.5;E. Differences between the Swiss Legal System and Directive 99/44;590
6.23.6;F. Future Prospects;592
6.24;Third Persons’ Liability for Non-conformity in Sales Contracts and Sellers’ Right of Redress in Turkey;594
6.24.1;A. An Overview of Turkish Sales Law;594
6.24.2;B. The Adoption of the Consumer Protection Acquis in Turkey;595
6.24.3;C. Development of the Special Provisions Regarding Consumer Sales;595
6.24.4;D. Guarantees;599
6.24.5;E. Liability of Third Persons alongside the Seller in Case of Contractual Non- conformity;601
6.24.6;F. The Seller’s Right of Redress;608
6.24.7;G. Outlook;613