Go / Atienza | Learning by Refraction | E-Book | www.sack.de
E-Book

E-Book, Englisch, 158 Seiten

Go / Atienza Learning by Refraction

A Practitioner's Guide to 21st-Century Ignatian Pedagogy
1. Auflage 2019
ISBN: 978-971-550-906-0
Verlag: Ateneo de Manila University Press
Format: EPUB
Kopierschutz: 0 - No protection

A Practitioner's Guide to 21st-Century Ignatian Pedagogy

E-Book, Englisch, 158 Seiten

ISBN: 978-971-550-906-0
Verlag: Ateneo de Manila University Press
Format: EPUB
Kopierschutz: 0 - No protection



'Learning by Refraction offers a fresh take on Ignatian pedagogy, curating what's most helpful from the latest education research and consolidating what has been tried and tested. A must-read for all educators, even those who may not know Ignatian pedagogy.'


- Fr. Jose Ramon T. Villarin, SJ
President, Ateneo de Manila University, Philippines

Go / Atienza Learning by Refraction jetzt bestellen!

Weitere Infos & Material


CHAPTER 3

LEARNING THROUGH REFLECTION AND ACTION

ACTIVITY   

CONVERSE with COLLEAGUES

  Recall one successful, memorable, and perhaps even exhilarating learning experience—not necessarily academic.

— Herbert Simon (1996)

How has the meaning of learning changed over the years?

Learning used to be defined almost exclusively in terms of knowing. In an English class, for instance, do the students know the rules of grammar, e.g., noun-verb agreement, active/passive voices, etc.? In Science, is the class familiar with the parts of the cell and their functions, or Newton’s law of gravitation? In History, can students recall the significant dates and events in Ancient Rome?

Consequently, the question that teachers used to ask to assess learning was: Do the students ‘know’ the facts in the textbooks, the concepts discussed by the teacher, or the knowledge imparted in class? In other words, can students identify, enumerate, and label these in the exams?

But today because of technology, the very definition of knowing has changed from simply “being able to remember and repeat information to being able to find and use it” (Simon, 1996).

Before Google, most information was available only through hard copies of books and articles or from video cassette tapes, written and produced by experts. Students, therefore, had to learn all the information they might one day need in the world—also known as “just-in-case learning” (Collins & Halverson, 2009).

These days, the ability to recall and repeat information no longer has as much premium. Any child today can search the Internet for all the information we used to have to store in our brains. Because all that is so readily accessible today—literally just a click away whenever needed—it no longer makes much sense to memorize facts and concepts. We can learn anything when we need to—known as “just-in-time learning” (Wharton, 2000).

Yet most educators today retain the outmoded conflation of learning with recall, and their default method to determine whether or not students have learned is simply by checking their students’ memory.

Teacher-centered, textbook-driven, and test-oriented teaching leads to an almost exclusive focus on a “one simple right answer” type of learning, which results in the two common learning ailments that afflict our students today:

1.   Academic Amnesia:

when students forget everything ten minutes after regurgitating all the content at the exam, and

2.   Intellectual Constipation:

when students’ knowledge is so rigid that they do not know how to apply it beyond the test.

The reason for academic amnesia is a lack of understanding. Students forget what they have memorized for the test because in the absence of an organizing framework, they have no way of retrieving something they do not understand.

The reason for intellectual constipation, on the other hand, is that students have not been guided on how to use and apply what they have learned at the outset.

Learning in the 21st century can no longer consist merely of recall. Learning today has to include both understanding of content and its application in the world. These are the key components in the kind of learning that we consider essential in the 21st century.

To promote understanding and application, Refractive Learning emphasizes two student tasks central to learning: Reflection and Action.

Learning through Reflection

Learning today can no longer be limited to “knowing about”; it needs to include understanding. Understanding is not the same as merely “knowing a lot of stuff” about something, a distinction made by education experts like Perkins (2014) and Wiggins and McTighe (2005). It entails much more than just storing a lot of information in your head. It connotes aiming for depth rather than breadth.

An obvious example would be a traditional History lesson. Students may know all the significant dates and names associated with historical events, but all this factual knowledge does not guarantee understanding. Students should learn to appreciate the significance of these events, analyze their underlying causes and implications, relate these events to other historical events, and justify how their claims make sense.

ACTIVITY   

CONNECT to CONTEXT

  When it premiered in 2007, “Are You Smarter than a Fifth Grader” quickly became a popular game show that aired in the US. Audiences got a kick out of seeing adults, even professionals, struggle to answer questions that were lifted out of elementary textbooks and often rely on the help of actual fifth graders to answer them.

When you think about it, many winners of academic competitions (e.g., quiz bees) “know a lot of stuff” that they may not actually need to be fully functioning adults.

List down the things your student should be able to do if s/he “just knows a lot of stuff about something” and if s/he “has a deeper understanding of something” in the correct column:

Adapted from Wiggins and McTighe (2004)

In most classrooms, understanding happens quite by accident: Teachers “teach by telling,” and a handful of their students may, often by sheer luck, stumble across some insight. As Wiggins and McTighe (2005) famously claimed, this habit of covering the subject matter does not facilitate understanding among the students. Teachers need to be purposeful in helping students “uncover” the principles and connections underlying the taught concepts and facts. The best way to help students to understand is by teaching Reflection.

Teachers, after all, can never directly cause understanding. All we can do is design our classes so that students are furnished the opportunity and support to engage in tasks that will hopefully lead to understanding.

Learners understand as a result of their exercise of Reflection. Reflection entails a thoughtful pulling apart of ideas to appreciate their underlying principles, as well as a stepping back in order to see how the ideas connect with others and fit in the bigger picture. This is the reason why Refractive Learning is Reflection-driven.

ACTIVITY   

CONVERSE with COLLEAGUES

  In his classic, , John Dewey (1997) talks about the need for educators to train their students how to think. Below are three quotations from the book that describe what he calls “reflective thought.”

For Dewey, reflective thought is prompted by the following conditions:

   A provocative question or a puzzling problem

   A challenge to current understanding

   Ambiguity or doubt

In short, it is a sense of uncertaintya question or problem that poses a challenge to current understanding and thus provokes inquirythat activates Reflection. Note that this is contrary to our teachers’ instincts since we try to make things as clear as possible to our students.

Ignatian Connection

“At this level of reflection, the memory, the understanding, the imagination, and the feelings are used to capture the meaning and the essential value of what is being studied, to discover its relationship with other aspects of knowledge and human activity, and to appreciate its implications in the ongoing search for truth and freedom.”

“We use the term reflection to mean a thoughtful reconsideration of some subject matter, experience, idea, purpose, or spontaneous reaction, in order to grasp its significance more fully. Thus, reflection is the process by which meaning surfaces in human experience” (, 1993,...



Ihre Fragen, Wünsche oder Anmerkungen
Vorname*
Nachname*
Ihre E-Mail-Adresse*
Kundennr.
Ihre Nachricht*
Lediglich mit * gekennzeichnete Felder sind Pflichtfelder.
Wenn Sie die im Kontaktformular eingegebenen Daten durch Klick auf den nachfolgenden Button übersenden, erklären Sie sich damit einverstanden, dass wir Ihr Angaben für die Beantwortung Ihrer Anfrage verwenden. Selbstverständlich werden Ihre Daten vertraulich behandelt und nicht an Dritte weitergegeben. Sie können der Verwendung Ihrer Daten jederzeit widersprechen. Das Datenhandling bei Sack Fachmedien erklären wir Ihnen in unserer Datenschutzerklärung.